Critics Accuse Mayor Mamdani of Weakening Protections for Jewish New Yorkers on First Day in Office

Newly sworn-in New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing sharp criticism from pro-Israel groups and Jewish community advocates following a series of policy reversals announced on his first day in office, actions they say have made Jewish New Yorkers less safe.

Among the most contentious moves was the revocation of New York City’s use of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, a framework widely adopted by governments to identify contemporary antisemitism, including cases linked to anti-Zionist rhetoric.

“The IHRA definition was the city’s most effective tool for recognizing modern antisemitism,” one Jewish advocacy leader said. “Removing it sends a dangerous message at a time when antisemitic incidents are rising.”

Mayor Mamdani also rescinded the city’s anti-BDS executive order, a policy that previously limited New York City’s engagement with organizations supporting the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel. Critics argue the decision legitimizes economic pressure against Israel.

“Eliminating the anti-BDS order signals that economic warfare against the world’s only Jewish state is now acceptable under city policy,” a spokesperson for a pro-Israel coalition said.

In addition, the administration rolled back NYPD guidance designed to monitor and restrict protests near synagogues, measures that were introduced after several Jewish institutions were targeted during demonstrations in recent years.

“These safeguards were put in place because synagogues were being singled out,” said a former city official familiar with the policy. “Removing them leaves Jewish worshippers exposed.”

The mayor further dissolved New York City–Israel economic cooperation initiatives, ending formal partnerships between the city and Israeli-American businesses and organizations.

“Cutting these ties undermines decades of economic and cultural collaboration,” a business leader said. “It alienates a community that has long contributed to New York’s growth.”

As of press time, City Hall had not issued a detailed response to the criticisms, though allies of the mayor maintain the changes reflect a broader shift toward civil liberties, free expression, and a reassessment of the city’s international relationships.

The developments have intensified debate just hours into Mamdani’s administration, signaling that issues surrounding antisemitism, Israel, and public safety will remain flashpoints in New York City politics.