US Supreme Court reinstates Idaho abortion ban pending appeal
The US Supreme Court has decided to reimpose a near-total abortion ban in Idaho while the court reviews an appeal against the controversial law. The conservative-leaning court, which previously overturned the constitutional right to abortion in June 2022, has scheduled oral arguments for the Idaho case in April.
Idaho currently maintains some of the strictest anti-abortion regulations in the nation, permitting the procedure solely when the pregnant mother is at imminent risk of death. The Biden administration has challenged the law, asserting that it conflicts with a federal statute mandating hospitals receiving government Medicare funding to provide emergency room medical care, including abortion, in serious but not necessarily life-threatening situations.
The Justice Department contends that Idaho’s law lacks adequate protection for physicians, leaving them susceptible to arrest and criminal prosecution. The law permits abortion only when necessary to prevent the death of the pregnant woman, offering no defense for situations where the health of the patient is at stake.
A federal judge in Boise issued a preliminary injunction in August 2022, blocking the state law on the grounds that it placed doctors in a challenging ethical position. Following the US Supreme Court’s decision to overturn the constitutional right to abortion, states have gained the authority to establish their own laws regarding the procedure.
The impact of restrictive abortion laws is evident, with reports emerging of a Texas woman being compelled to leave the state for an emergency abortion due to barriers to terminating her potentially life-threatening pregnancy. In Texas, physicians providing abortions now face severe penalties, including up to 99 years in prison, fines up to $100,000, and the revocation of their medical licenses.
Idaho’s “Defense of Life Act” stipulates a potential five-year prison sentence for those performing abortions. President Joe Biden expressed concern over the Supreme Court’s decision, emphasizing that it allows Idaho’s extreme abortion ban to resume, denying women critical emergency abortion care mandated by federal law. Biden criticized the court’s 2022 decision, stating that it empowers Republican officials to pursue restrictive abortion bans, jeopardizing women’s health and creating obstacles for doctors providing essential care.
About The Author
